Simply Piano alternative without a subscription: Klavierlicht compared
Simply Piano is one of the best-known apps for learning piano from scratch. Klavierlicht is something different: a practice tool for people who already have a keyboard or piano and do not want another subscription. This article says where Simply Piano is clearly stronger, where Klavierlicht fits better, and what each costs. I build Klavierlicht, so read the comparison with that in mind.
Where Simply Piano is strong
Simply Piano walks beginners through courses step by step. It also has songs you know and a very large user base: in the Swiss App Store it has over 21,000 ratings and in the German one over 84,000, at an average of 4.68 (as of 7 November 2026). The app listens through the microphone and, according to its store listing, can connect to a MIDI piano. It is available in 14 languages and runs on iPhone, iPad and Android.
If you are starting from zero, want to be guided and like playing well-known songs, Simply Piano is the better choice. Klavierlicht does not teach you piano from the ground up.
Where Klavierlicht is different
Klavierlicht is less a course than a tool for targeted practice, above all with a MIDI keyboard:
- No subscription. You unlock once: CHF 6 for iPad or CHF 29 for iPad and Mac. No account, no ads, no expiry date.
- Finds weak bars. Klavierlicht notices which bars you miss or hesitate in and practises exactly those with you, instead of making you replay the whole piece.
- Tempo staircase and hand ladder. The tempo rises by itself once a run was clean. Right hand first, then left, then both.
- Your own pieces. You can load your own MIDI and MusicXML files, and one of them stays free permanently. I found no import of your own MIDI files in Simply Piano's store listing.
- 222 public-domain classical pieces are included, plus a course of folk songs and classical music.
- Data stays on your device. Music, history and settings do not leave it. The exception is the optional AI tips: only if you explicitly agree does a practice report go to a Klavierlicht server, which passes it on to an AI provider in the USA.
- iPad and Mac. You get both versions in one purchase if you choose "iPad and Mac".

What Klavierlicht does not have
- No licensed pop songs. Public-domain classical music and folk songs, otherwise only what you bring yourself as MIDI or MusicXML.
- No video courses and no guided path from zero. Klavierlicht assumes a keyboard and the will to practise in a targeted way.
- Apple only: iPad and Mac. There is nothing for Android or Windows.
- The microphone is a beta. Klavierlicht is most reliable with a MIDI keyboard; that is the precise way to use it. For an acoustic piano the microphone listens along, less reliably with chords than with single notes.
The comparison at a glance
As of November 2026.
| Simply Piano | Klavierlicht | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | subscription | one-time, no subscription |
| Price (Swiss App Store, cheapest yearly offers) | CHF 124 to 190 per year | CHF 6 (iPad) or CHF 29 (iPad and Mac), one-time |
| Guided courses | yes, extensive | one small course of folk songs and classical |
| Well-known songs | yes, licensed | no; public-domain classical and your own files |
| Your own MIDI/MusicXML pieces | not shown in the store listing | yes, one permanently free |
| Finds weak bars and drills them | not shown in the store listing | yes, with tempo staircase and hand ladder |
| Microphone | yes | beta |
| Devices | iPhone, iPad, Android | iPad, Mac |
| Account and ads | - | no account, no ads |
Sources: Swiss App Store listings, as of 17 November 2026. Prices come from the in-app purchases, which do not always state the term; they can differ by country and promotion. A "-" means: not checked. Check at the time of purchase.
Who each one suits
Simply Piano suits you if you are starting from scratch, want guidance, want to learn well-known songs, or are accompanying a child. The subscription is then the price of the finished learning path.
Klavierlicht suits you if you already have a MIDI keyboard or piano, work on individual pieces, and want an app that shows which bars do not sit yet and brings them up to tempo. And if you do not want another subscription.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a piano app without a subscription?
Yes. You unlock Klavierlicht once: CHF 6 for iPad or CHF 29 for iPad and Mac. There is no subscription, no account and no ads. One piece of your own stays free permanently.
Can Klavierlicht replace Simply Piano?
Only partly. Klavierlicht has no guided video courses and no licensed pop songs. If you have a keyboard and want to work on pieces in a targeted way, it offers weak-bar detection, a tempo staircase and a hand ladder. If you are starting from scratch, Simply Piano serves you better.
Do I need a MIDI keyboard?
Klavierlicht is most accurate with a MIDI keyboard. For an acoustic piano there is a microphone mode, which is still a beta. To try it out, your device keyboard is enough.
What happens to my data?
Music, history and settings stay on your device. A practice report leaves it only if you explicitly allow the optional AI tips.
Try it yourself
The app is free to download. The trial contains one course piece, one piece of your own choice, the first three pieces of "Klassik · Einstieg", three workshop exercises and the first ear-training level. If you like it, you unlock everything with a single purchase: CHF 6 for iPad or CHF 29 for iPad and Mac. No subscription.
Get it on the App StoreKeep reading: Synthesia alternative for iPad · flowkey alternative with your own MIDI keyboard · Skoove alternative without a subscription · Learning piano as an adult · Practising piano with a MIDI keyboard · Connecting a MIDI keyboard to iPad and Mac · Public-domain piano pieces for beginners